Can Locksmiths Craft a Key from a Broken One?

US Locksmith is a licensed (Lic #00443LK) locksmith company serving all of South Florida since 2004. Yes; a licensed locksmith can extract a broken key and cut a new one from the fragment.

Can a Locksmith Make a New Key from a Snapped Key?

Yes. A skilled locksmith can extract a broken key fragment from a lock and cut a brand-new working key from the pieces. The process requires specialized extraction tools, a key-cutting machine, and the expertise to read the remaining key cuts accurately. In most cases, the locksmith can complete the extraction, cut a new key, and test it on-site within 20 to 40 minutes, no need to replace the entire lock.

How Does a Locksmith Extract a Broken Key?

The extraction process follows a careful sequence to avoid damaging the lock's internal pins and springs. Here is what a licensed locksmith in Fort Lauderdale does when you call about a broken key:

1. Assess the situation. Determine how deep the fragment is lodged and whether any pins are binding against it
2. Apply lubricant: a light spray into the keyway loosens the fragment and reduces friction during extraction
3. Use extraction tools. Specialized hook picks or spiral extractors grip the key fragment and pull it out without pushing it deeper
4. Inspect the lock: check the cylinder for internal damage from the break, including bent pins or scratched chambers
5. Cut a new key. Using the broken pieces as a reference, the locksmith cuts a new key that matches the original bitting
6. Test the new key: insert and turn several times to confirm smooth operation before finishing the job

How Much Does Broken Key Extraction Cost in South Florida?

Broken key extraction and replacement typically costs between $75 and $150 in South Florida, depending on the lock type and time of day. Emergency or after-hours service may cost more. US Locksmith provides upfront pricing before starting work, so there are no surprises.

When Should You Replace the Lock Instead?

If the lock was already worn before the key snapped, sticking, grinding, or requiring extra force to turn, the break was a symptom of a deeper problem. In that case, replacing the entire lock is the smarter move. A professional locksmith can assess whether the cylinder was damaged during the break and recommend extraction-only or full replacement based on what they find.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a locksmith make a key from a broken key? +

Yes. A licensed locksmith can piece together the broken fragments, read the key cuts, and cut a new working key on-site. Both halves of the broken key are helpful, but a skilled locksmith can often work with just one piece or decode the lock directly if the fragment is too damaged to read.

How long does broken key extraction take? +

Most broken key extractions take 10 to 20 minutes. Cutting a new key from the fragment adds another 10 to 15 minutes. The total process, extraction, new key, and testing, is usually done within 30 to 40 minutes on-site.

Will the lock still work after a broken key is extracted? +

In most cases, yes. If the extraction is done with proper tools and technique, the lock's internal components remain undamaged. The locksmith will test the lock with the new key before finishing. If the lock was damaged, the locksmith will let you know before proceeding with a replacement.

Why do keys break in locks? +

Keys break for several reasons: worn or weakened metal from years of use, forcing a stuck key instead of addressing the underlying lock issue, extreme temperatures that make metal brittle, or using a key that was poorly cut with uneven stress points. Regular lock maintenance helps prevent breaks.

How much does it cost to extract a broken key in South Florida? +

Broken key extraction in South Florida typically costs $75 to $150, including a new key cut from the fragment. After-hours or emergency service may add $25 to $75. US Locksmith provides transparent pricing upfront; call 1-866-776-6062 for a quote.